Skilled Independent (subclass 189) vs Skilled Migrant Category
Australia · SC 189vs New Zealand · SMC
The SMC is the faster route (1–18 months), the SMC is cheaper on official fees (≈ US$3,900), both lead to permanent residency. Which fits depends on your nationality, profession, and whether you already have a job offer, the breakdown below maps each visa to a profile.
Maintained by Senne Bels, Founder, Transita
If you're weighing Australia against New Zealand for skilled migration, these are the two flagship points-tested routes, and both grant residence on approval. The difference is the employer: Australia's Skilled Independent 189 needs 65 points and an invitation from SkillSelect but no employer, where the real bottleneck is selection. New Zealand's Skilled Migrant Category sets a 6-point bar but needs a skilled job, or an offer of one, with an accredited employer, and processing takes 1–18 months. Salaries and job markets usually matter more than the visa mechanics, so weigh where you'd actually want to work.
SC 189 vs SMC: what are the key differences?
official sources: SC 189 · immi.homeaffairs.gov.au·SC 189 success-rate data · immi.homeaffairs.gov.au·SMC · immigration.govt.nz
Which visa should you choose: SC 189 or SMC?
- 01
Ease of selection
Pick SC 189AU 189 needs 65 points and a SkillSelect invitation (competitive)
Pick SMCNZ SMC has a lower 6-point threshold
- 02
Age limit
Pick SC 18944 or younger at invitation
Pick SMCUp to 55 for SMC
- 03
Cost
Pick SC 189Pick Australia's Skilled Independent (subclass 189) if its other advantages are worth a higher government fee (AUD 6,135 (≈ US$4,310) against ≈ US$3,900).
Pick SMCPick New Zealand's Skilled Migrant Category if upfront cost matters: its government fee is ≈ US$3,900 against AUD 6,135 (≈ US$4,310) for Australia's Skilled Independent (subclass 189).
- 04
Economy and salaries
Pick SC 189Larger job market, higher median wages
Pick SMCSmaller market, often faster lifestyle relocation
Common questions
- Is the Skilled Independent (subclass 189) or the Skilled Migrant Category faster to get?
- The Skilled Migrant Category (SMC) is typically faster, around 1–18 months, versus 6–18 months for the Skilled Independent (subclass 189). Real timelines depend on the country's caseload and how complete your application is.
- Which costs more, the SC 189 or the SMC?
- The Skilled Independent (subclass 189) (SC 189) costs more, AUD 6,135 (≈ US$4,310) in official fees, versus ≈ US$3,900 for the Skilled Migrant Category (SMC). Both figures are government fees only and exclude legal, translation, and relocation costs.
- Can I get permanent residency with the Skilled Independent (subclass 189) or the Skilled Migrant Category?
- The SC 189 offers a direct path to permanent residency, while the SMC offers a direct path to permanent residency. If long-term settlement is the goal, weight the route with the clearer PR pathway more heavily.
- Does the SC 189 or the SMC need a job offer?
- The Skilled Migrant Category (SMC) requires a job offer or employer sponsor, while the Skilled Independent (subclass 189) (SC 189) does not, you can apply on your own profile. That makes the SC 189 more accessible if you don't yet have an employer lined up.
Read the full pathway
Skilled Independent (subclass 189)
Australia's points-tested permanent residency visa with no state sponsorship or employer required.
Full SC 189 guideSkilled Migrant Category
Points-based selection for skilled workers. Lower threshold than Canada Express Entry or AU SkillSelect. Path to PR after meeting points + employment requirements.
Full SMC guideStill can't decide?
Your workspace scores your profile against SC 189, SMC, and 60+ other pathways and shows which is the best fit, with the why. Answer 8 questions to set up your free workspace. You see which routes you appear to qualify for, what may block each one and the official page to check.
Build my workspaceThe workspace is free. The optional $9 plan adds the document checklist for each route with its costs and lead times, the gaps between your profile and each route, and a suggested filing order. Fees are estimates. General information, not legal advice.